Tile Roofs vs. Shingle Roofs: What’s the Difference, and Which Is Right for Me?

There are many different roof types available for homeowners to consider — so much so that it can be difficult to determine which is best suited for their home. Comparing each roofing option naturally raises questions like, “is a tile roof better than shingles?” Unfortunately, there’s no clear-cut answer. 

With that said, it is possible to solve the roof tiles vs. shingles debate. If you’re comparing the two, here’s a look at both shingle and tile roofing options and how to determine which is right for you.

What Are Shingle Roofs?

Shingles are one of the more common roofing materials in the United States, often made with asphalt, slate, shake, and wood. These rectangular and flexible shingles overlap with one another to protect homes from the elements. Shingles come in several different color and texture varieties, allowing homeowners to pick a style that best matches their homes’ aesthetic. Some kinds of shingles can even replicate the appearance of other materials, granting extra design versatility.

What Are Tile Roofs?

Tile roofs come in different patterns and shapes, which intersect each other to stave off rainwater. They’re installed in parallel rows and are sealed to the roof to offer additional durability. The tiles come in a wide assortment of materials, including clay, concrete, and metal, allowing homeowners to implement a unique appearance for their roofing. 

Roof Tiles Vs. Shingles: Which Is Better?

While both tiles and shingles have their own pros and cons, there’s no objectively better roofing style. Instead, the answer to the roof tiles vs. shingles question largely depends on a homeowner’s unique circumstances. Therefore, the best roofing material for you may not be the same for someone else. Here’s a look at five of the factors that can influence which kind of material is best suited for your roof:


In the roof tiles vs. shingles debate, the latter is the victor in regard to price. Asphalt shingles are generally less expensive to purchase per square foot than tiles, which are more expensive. Therefore, choose shingles when you’re on a tight budget.


Another advantage of asphalt shingle roofs is that their installation is relatively easy. Tile roof installations, meanwhile, can take several days to complete. If you’re looking for a faster and easier installation, shingles are your best bet.


Compared to asphalt shingles, tiles have better endurance and durability. This allows them to last much longer — when well-maintained, a tile roof may last up to 100 years! In terms of longevity, tiles will be a better investment in the long run.


Another factor homeowners must consider in the roof tiles vs. shingles debate is the weight of their roof. Asphalt shingles aren’t very heavy, allowing them to be installed on many different roofs. On the other hand, tiles require some form of reinforcement to support their high weights. If you’re unsure if your roof is able to withstand tiles, call a reliable roofing company or roofing contractors for an assessment.


While both shingles and tiles fare well in multiple climates, they offer unique advantages in each. For example, shingles function well in hot environments because they can be effective at reflecting sunlight. However, keep in mind that they are not immune to algae growth, meaning that asphalt shingles in more humid, tropical climates require special cleaning. 

Tiles can thrive in several environments, too — especially durable metal tiles. In particular, the thickness of tile roofs helps protect against freezing in cold weather, and their strength provides superior support for the weight of snow.

So, is a tile roof better than shingles or not? Whatever the case may be, 1 By 1 Roofing offers professional roof repair in Tucson for both. Additionally, our team provides a number of other home services, including our solar installations in Tucson, AZ. For more information and to schedule your appointment, call us today.

Contact Us Today To Schedule An Appointment!

Recent Blog Posts